10

Blogs

Blog

Public Displays of Violence
2014-04-06

I should premise by saying that I know violence is everywhere. It strikes in places of war, places of unrest, places where opportunity for betterment lacks. With that said, I can't shake the waves of anger I feel at the injustice of it all when witnessing acts of violence.

There have been many occasions in Beijing where I've witnessed people fighting in public with hordes of witnesses surrounding the altercation, simply watching what was going on without interfering. I'm a practical person - I don't think it is ever smart to get into the middle of a fight. However, I do also believe there are basic things that can be done to help stop public fighting. I also don't think that the "Bystander Effect" is something that happens exclusively in China. (It's that odd thing that happens when crowds of people witness but don't interfere with people who need help in public situations.) It happens everywhere in all sorts of social dynamics.

Something that happened in Shanghai the other day really stuck with me. My husband, myself and our aunt were heading back to People's Square to have a rest at the hotel. On the way to finding our exit in People's Square station, I noticed two men holding a third man between them and leading him to an exit rather roughly. As I watched this, I noticed that they promptly began to beat the third man they were leading outside right outside the window of a crowded McDonalds. I was shocked. Those kinds of things don't normally happen in crowded areas, much less in front of a window where dozens of people were having lunch.

What happened? Well, nothing for a while. People literally looked at what was going on while eating their food, while walking by the very exit where this man was being beaten into the ground. Luckily, those of us still in the station had the good sense to call some guards to the scene. It's something that I haven't seen happen often in China - people involving themselves to help someone else. (Again, China is not the only place where this happens.). The thing that got to me, however, was how nonchalant the guards were. They knew someone was being beaten up, they saw it with their own eyes, yet they walked towards the altercation as if they were having a nice stroll in the park. No amount of my calling out in Chinese, "Please, hurry!" could get them to make it to the scene in time.

Hence, the two men got all of the punches and kicks in that they wanted and managed to get away in time, leaving the third man cowering on the steps.

For me, it's not that this happened in China; it's not that the guards took too long to get to the man's aid. It's the sheer fact that there are still people out there who are not scared to be that violent in such a public way. I hate violence and injustice in every form. It is something that will unfortunately always exist in some form or another in our world.

Violence, in the end, benefits no one, not even the aggressor.

Comment

0/1000
AlexisFW85 2014-04-08 19:53

It was an unfortunate thing to witness, and sadly it wasn't my first experience. That's life though, isn't it? And you're right, you never know what the fight is really about...it's just a tough thing to deal with, seeing people in a helpless situation whether the aggressors felt justified or not in their actions.

AlexisFW85 2014-04-08 19:51

It is a tough line to walk, I agree. There are ways to help without getting directly involved...like I was saying to idorun, simply calling in the police would be a good and smart first step.

AlexisFW85 2014-04-08 19:49

Oh, I would definitely agree not to get directly involved in a fight. But there are other measures to take other than simply watching from a distance or pretending you didn't see it. I would never recommend someone to get directly involved because you never know what's really happening. Calling the police, leading them to the scene quickly would definitely be better options.

idorun 2014-04-07 19:33

Helping to stop a fight in China may get you in trouble . Especially if you are a western person , I have heard stories where a man tried to help a Chinese from being beaten up . The man who was being beat up accused the man who helped him , when the very slow police arrived . I don't know what happen after , this is one reason not too get involved in a fight .

xuedongi60 2014-04-07 10:57

As a Chinese,I was taught to help others who need help from my childhood,it is a good merit.In recent years,many news shows that many kind people who help others gained a bad result,such as being blackmailed. I always want to help the people,but when I remembered the news,I was confused.But my conscience strongly tell me that I should do something to help others who need help.

voice_cd 2014-04-07 09:25

Good job, we have recommended it.

ColinSpeakman 2014-04-06 15:13

If one is a journalist and writes an expose story in many countries in the world, expect to get beaten up for it pretty soon after. Violence is terrible in a civilized society but it can be a rule of law for some people. However, who knows what that dispute was about? There may have been two sides! Sorry you had to witness it!