Views: 5195|Replies: 4

why do u think USA intervene Taiwan Issue? [Copy link] 中文

Rank: 4

Post time 2003-12-10 12:59:19 |Display all floors
The obvious reason for USA to support Taiwan is the human right, but i think US does this(supplying the military force for Taiwan) is for its own good.

whatz its purporse?

Use magic tools Report

Rank: 1

Post time 2003-12-10 19:42:19 |Display all floors


There are both simple and complex reasons the US supports the current status of Taiwan.

Right or wrong, Americans consider themselves "guardians of democracy."  Americans feel that the spread of democracy promotes freedom, peace, stability and economic growth, as "consolidated" democracies encourage (a) the removal of corrupt and incompetent rulers through elections, (b) the allocation of economic resources in a more efficient and transparent way, and (c) an open and critical press, which monitors politicians and business to fortify democracy and the open economy.  This is good for America.  The growth of world democracy and open economies helps America by providing open, stable markets that increase American prosperity, while also helping the local country.  It is a mutually beneficial dynamic.  Today Taiwan is seen as moving towards consolidated democracy, which is defined as a democratic government that has seen a peaceful transfer of power to different political parties in successive elections, as well as a highly open economy, joining, for example, Australia, Canada, the European Union nations, South Korea, and the United States.  Japan, Singapore, and Hong Kong also have highly open economies, but politically they have been dominated by a single party, so one can argue they have a less consolidated democracy.  The People's Republic of China is viewed as a less open economy (recently ranked 100th in the world in one report, according to the Fraser Institute) and a non-democratic state.  Americans want Taiwan democracy to be an example for the development of the rest of China.  Americans fear that if Taiwan is returned to mainland China, before mainland China has the chance to reform itself into a modern democratic state with an open economy, the progress Taiwan has achieved in joining the developed world will be lost.  Americans are suspicious that China is using the "one-country, two-systems" approach in Hong Kong as a trap to lure Taiwan back, and then Beijing will terminate democracy in both Hong Kong and Taiwan.  

Now, you can argue that America's record as a guardian of democracy is mixed and hypocritical.  America has failed in Vietnam, the Philippines, and much of Africa, the Middle East, Latin America, and the former Soviet Union in promoting democracy and open economies.  And despite being democratic, America still attacks other countries.  But where it has been successful, in Europe, Japan, and South Korea, both America and those countries have benefited.  There are also many success stories in Asia, Africa, and Latin America.  And where America has failed, Americans pay the price of their failure.  By failing to support democracy and open economies in the Middle East, America has allowed terrorism and extremism to prosper and come back to threaten America itself.

Many Americans think an open, democratic China is good for the world, but they think a closed, un-democratic China is dangerous.  This may not be a correct analysis, but this is what many Americans truly think, based on their experience with countries like Germany, Japan, Russia, Iraq, and the Koreas.  Hu Jintao has said that China must encourage the growth of democracy, and Wen Jiabao praised Taiwanese democracy in a recent press conference in America.  Americans agree.

Use magic tools Report

Rank: 4

Post time 2003-12-11 18:41:39 |Display all floors

Thanks, Tuvalu

i agree with u on the democratic points. i think the mainland is moving towards a freer society, i like our new president Hu and premier Wen better. i hope one day the people in the mainland can have the same freedom on speech, actions as the people in Taiwan and the countries of the first world.

but progress has to be made without causing chaos and instability. China has a tough road ahead, but so long as the chinese people work hard together for a brighter future, the day in my dream will come .

thank u so much for replying my messege so much^-^

Use magic tools Report

Rank: 1

Post time 2003-12-31 16:43:48 |Display all floors

Maybe there still are many works for China to do on democratics

China open herself to outside,but politics may need reformation.We want to see a strong and democratic China.On that day,we needn't to use our weapons and our country will be unified.
But u.s have no right to intervene China's politics.Also,it's unwise for Chen to be so uncool.I guess,the bombs put besides the strait does work,but we really don't want to have war.Hope Chen can be cool down.Don't be so foolish.He will be striked if he don't change his speaking,the war which will destroy both sides will be unavoidable.

Use magic tools Report

Rank: 6Rank: 6

Post time 2003-12-31 22:02:32 |Display all floors

An excellent discussion!

To many people, it would seem as though the US is merely making trouble in the region.  However, here is another aspect to consider.  

Right or wrong, the US has historical ties to Taiwan, and has had friendly relations with the island over the last 50 years.  This friendship influences US policy and diplomacy.  From the US perspective, it would not be right to abandon a friend.  At the same time, the best outcome for all would be a peaceful reunification.  Therefore, the US walks a diplomatic tightrope that recognizes historical friendships, but also the desire to see reunification.

Use magic tools Report

You can't reply post until you log in Log in | register

Contact us:Tel: (86)010-84883548, Email:
Blog announcement:| We reserve the right, and you authorize us, to use content, including words, photos and videos, which you provide to our blog
platform, for non-profit purposes on China Daily media, comprising newspaper, website, iPad and other social media accounts.