Author: abramicus

Is Ukraine the Final Battlefield of Mankind? [Copy link] 中文

Rank: 8Rank: 8

Post time 2014-3-5 01:12:04 |Display all floors
ColinSpeakman Post time: 2014-3-4 08:49
There have been many that have rushed to comment that a split Ukraine is unthinkable. I am not so su ...

Ukraine is really a divided country, as it is.  Keeping the two sides together only ensures that one side will try to dominate the other, leading to a bloody civil war.  The backers of Kiev want the whole Ukraine, including Crimea, and it is this "unity in hostility" that will bring about the end of both parts of Ukraine, whereas separate, the two sides can at least peacefully coexist with each other.  Besides, Crimea was annexed into Ukraine by Khruschev, not by the consent of the Crimeans, and therefore, the bond between Crimea and Urkaine is quite artificial.  But Kiev wants Crimea because, precisely because, it is dominated by the Russians it hates, and therefore, the desire to have Crimea is not one borne of love, but rather of hatred, which no Crimean will accept, and thus, the way the current situation is structured, more conflicts are inevitable.

Russia should make a clean job of its intervention in Crimea by finding a boundary that is defensible by Crimea, but tolerable by Kiev.  It should not leave Crimea too small or isolated to defend, nor should it be too big for Kiev to tolerate.  But above all, such a border should be found and enforced before more blood is shed, precisely in order to prevent such bloodshed on both sides.

A referee, even if he is the brother of one of the fighters, if he truly aims for peace, would separate the two fighters far enough so that no one fighter can take a jab at the other.  Russia's problem is that it may not have enough power to enforce a mandatory distance of separation between Kiev and Crimea, or insert itself as the buffer zone between the two.  With all the kibitzers crying foul and howling at him, Putin may be paralyzed in his actions to allow the two sides to take jabs at each other, when he in fact should ban such actions by occupying for now at least, the future DMZ between Kiev and Crimea.

Use magic tools Report

Rank: 8Rank: 8

Post time 2014-3-5 05:58:57 |Display all floors
craig32935 Post time: 2014-3-3 23:42
Quote: Obama is posing as a "muscular patriot"

As I spit coffee all over my keyboard in laughter ...

Don't blame you! Nevertheless, I'm one of those "liberal Canadians" who favors Obama over the GOP. He just has to TRY appearing macho for the Democrats in Nov. Both Putin and Obama are putting on acts for domestic political reasons. But I think this crisis is cooling.
What's on your mind...

Use magic tools Report

Rank: 6Rank: 6

Post time 2014-3-5 06:13:33 |Display all floors
think so too

might be resolved by weekend.

Putin shows the world he means business
Ukraine knows if it wants to lean towards the west it cant do so with a Russian speaking populace that wants to lean the other way
so Crimea and perhaps another region with be cut loose.
Just have to dress it up as a win win for everyone.

Use magic tools Report

You can't reply post until you log in Log in | register

Contact us:Tel: (86)010-84883548, Email:
Blog announcement:| We reserve the right, and you authorize us, to use content, including words, photos and videos, which you provide to our blog
platform, for non-profit purposes on China Daily media, comprising newspaper, website, iPad and other social media accounts.