Chinadaily BBS - China Today - When Taiwan unites, Should Chen Shui Bian be tried in Chinese court for treason?

Guest: Login | Register | Search | FAQ

Chinadaily BBS » News Talk» China Today» When Taiwan unites, Should Chen Shui Bian be tried in Chinese court for treason?

Last Thread

Next Thread

sky_net
Primary Member
Rank: 2

UID 85736
Digest Posts 0
Credits 84
Posts 73
Registered 2005-11-20
Status Offline

When Taiwan unites, Should Chen Shui Bian be tried in Chinese court for treason?

I am confident that Taiwan will return to China within the next decade whether by military force or peaceful unification. So once Taiwan reunites with China, should Chen Shui Bian and his DDP party members be tried in Chinese court for treason? And what should be his punishment?

2007-3-5 02:03 PM

mencius (亞聖孟子)
Senior Member
Rank: 4

UID 47051
Digest Posts 1
Credits 3629
Posts 3419
Registered 2004-12-1
Location Great Britain
Status Offline

QUOTE:

Originally posted by sky_net at 5-3-2007 06:03
I am confident that Taiwan will return to China within the next decade whether by military force or peaceful unification. So once Taiwan reunites with China, should Chen Shui Bian and his DDP party members be tried in Chinese court for treason?

Unfortunately for you, Taiwan will never willingly allow China control of its judicial system. So if there was peaceful unification, you would never have the chance.

If China invaded Taiwan, trying Chen for treason would just make him a martyr and make Taiwanese even more likely to resist Chinese occupation.

2007-3-6 02:51 AM

forestservan
Junior Member
Rank: 3

UID 59604
Digest Posts 0
Credits 1231
Posts 1225
Registered 2005-3-17
Status Offline

If China has to take back Taipei by force, there will not be any trial.

All Taiwan officials will somehow be snatched by UFO, and life will go on as usual.

God blesses all,

Forest Servant.

[ Last edited by forestservan at 2007-3-8 07:33 AM ]

2007-3-6 07:29 AM

admchengho (Taiko)
Junior Member
Rank: 3

UID 44283
Digest Posts 1
Credits 775
Posts 758
Registered 2004-11-8
Location Xinshan, M'sia
Status Offline

I don't think we'll be able to charge Chen Shuibian as he will flee before the reunification or after sensing pro-China sentiments are growing in the province.

John B: "the murder and torture of millions of Chinese citizens from the "GLF" through to 1989"

A false statement.

2007-3-7 11:51 AM

kasper
Newcomer
Rank: 1

UID 129783
Digest Posts 0
Credits 3
Posts 3
Registered 2007-3-16
Status Offline

Remember that Chen Shui-bian did not become a president out of the blue! He is a product of a long, democratic process in Taiwan and he has been elected by millions of taiwanese people. He is merely a mouthpiece of the pro-independence movement i Taiwan and therefore it would give no sense at all to try him if(!) China and Taiwan ever will unite.

2007-3-16 03:17 PM

convair1948
Primary Member
Rank: 2

UID 127210
Digest Posts 0
Credits 425
Posts 423
Registered 2007-2-16
Status Offline

Reply #7 upyours's post

Calm Down upyours! The ravings you are being given by china mainlanders, are matters of national pride - and nothing more. On 3 seperate occassions now, China has threatened possible armed conflict, and 3 times now has not done so. Their is a reason - and anyone who has a lick of sense knows this.

Although the future of Taiwan is uncertain, till negotiation and diplomacy are expended, Taiwan remains independant !

2007-3-19 04:09 AM

socrateets
Primary Member
Rank: 2

UID 128734
Digest Posts 0
Credits 170
Posts 157
Registered 2007-3-7
Status Offline

that question is the same as asking if after unification, assuming the political system of taiwan was allowed most political power, should the leader of the mainland be tried for treason

2007-3-27 03:50 PM

wertynest
Primary Member
Rank: 2

UID 132992
Digest Posts 0
Credits 187
Posts 186
Registered 2007-4-13
Status Offline

DDP say what it wants, China is a free-speech country (check your constitution).
And if you want reunification, it means that Taiwan is not Chinese (???) Then why would they obey Chinese law??? And what Chinese law are they not inforcing? Displeasing your nationalistic feelings?
I just don't get it. Is there any logic in all this crap about Taiwan?

2007-4-16 12:52 PM

Printable Version | Email to Friend | Subscription | Favorites


Forum Rules	Feedback	Privacy